Ohio: A rising star in applied quantum | Part 1 of 3
Rather than replacing standard servers or AI, quantum computing works alongside classical hardware to tackle massive molecular, cryptography, and optimization challenges—creating prime opportunities for Ohio's healthcare, defense, and manufacturing sectors to lead real-world innovation.
By Dave Brewster
When quantum computers hit a new milestone, the milestones rightfully make the press. A great deal of innovation has occurred within quantum information sciences, and the advancement seems to be accelerating. As a long-time enterprise UNIX/Linux administrator, I’ve found myself studying quantum not only as a responsibility in my role at JobsOhio, but out of fascination with the technology.
For many, the natural assumption is that quantum computers are the next generation of the computer, the next generation of data center servers, supercomputers, or even AI. That assumption is misleading and needs correcting because it misses the point of what's actually happening. Quantum computers are not the next generation of classical computer and they are not AI. Quantum is a different tool for a different job. They will co-exist with classical computers, each doing what it does best.
Classical computers are still the best at the general sort of things we do on a day-to-day basis, such as word processing, browsing, gaming, administrative tasks, and the handling of large amounts of data.
Quantum computers are good at a very specific set of problems: those which involve massive parallelism, optimization, simulation, cryptography and complex scientific modeling. These are problems which are either very difficult or simply impossible for a classical computer to solve in a reasonable amount of time.
Start with what classical computers are absolutely superb at, which is pretty much everything. If you write a document, stream a film, play a game, run payroll, or use business intelligence or enterprise resource planning software, you're using a machine designed for that. It's a machine that takes a set of instructions and executes them, step by step, at a rate of billions per second with a very high degree of accuracy. Modern processors are very accurate and fairly cheap; many can run at room temperature, and after 60 years of engineering, we have a machine that does the job. The global economy is built on that model, and it will remain so. A quantum computer will never be able to edit a spreadsheet better than the computer on your desk. That's not a limitation; that's not what a quantum computer is designed to do.
So what are quantum computers for? The classical computer (even the most powerful supercomputer you can imagine) has one fundamental structural flaw in that it can only consider the possibilities one at a time or in small groups. That's quite adequate for the vast majority of problems, including the data intensive ones. There are however certain classes of problem which grow in complexity so rapidly that the classical machine is hopeless. The classic example is the simulation of a single molecule. The behavior of a drug candidate is determined by the quantum interactions of the electrons and the number of possible configurations grows so fast that the classical machine is completely out of its depth almost immediately. The same thing happens with optimization problems (routing a fleet of delivery vehicles through a hundred cities, or optimizing a financial portfolio) and, of course, modern cryptography, which underpins all our bank transactions and is based on problems such as factoring huge numbers. That's precisely the type of problem that the classical computer is absolutely hopeless at.
Quantum computers go about these problems in a completely different way. Instead of working with definite bits, they work with fragile quantum states that can represent many different possibilities at the same time, then use quantum interference so the wrong answers cancel out and the right ones get amplified. Nature is fundamentally quantum, so a machine that speaks the language of quantum can simulate chemistry directly rather than just approximate it. That's why all the realistic applications (drug discovery, new materials, battery chemistry, logistics and ultimately code breaking) all have that exponential character. For other applications, though, classical computers win hands down on cost, speed, reliability, and practicality.
That division of labor between classical and quantum computing isn't a disappointment. That's the whole point of it, really. They're solving different problems.
A good first filter is: is your team routinely simplifying the problem because the exact version is just too computationally expensive to solve? Is the root of that difficulty the quantum nature of the molecules and materials in question or a very tightly structured mathematical problem? If the answer to that is yes then you very likely have a quantum candidate that is worth a proper look. If the problem is essentially one of data volume or a Monte Carlo / optimization problem where 'good enough' is already sufficient then classical HPC and AI will almost certainly remain the better bet for the foreseeable future.
I’m bullish on quantum in Ohio. Ohio has the manufacturing base, the aerospace and defense base, the healthcare base, the materials and chemicals base. It has a burgeoning quantum infrastructure and a genuine opportunity to apply quantum to early, high-value applications. We have enormous growth potential as we further invest in applications, quantum startups, integrators, and services.
Dave Brewster is JobsOhio's Managing Director, Technology Industry. This is Part I of a three-part series, "Ohio: A Rising Star in Applied Quantum" by Dave Brewster. Up next in Part II: Building Ohio’s Quantum Information Sciences Workforce.